Skip to Main Content

Sewanee Logo

Jessie Ball duPont Library

LibGuide Redesign Prototype

Is This Good Information?

When you approach a scholarly article, you want to make sure that it will help you answer your research question.

  • Read the abstract first
  • Read the conclusion
  • If both of these sound like the kind of information you're looking for, read the rest of the article

screenshot capture of the entire Scholarly Articles guide from University of Illinois Undergraduate LibraryIdentify and Read Scholarly Sources

This guide from the University of Illinois provides a helpful flow chart, video, and infographic to help you navigate scholarly (aka peer reviewed, aka academic) sources.

 

Beware of...

articles and books that you find on Google Scholar. Most will be fine, but some might not be as scholarly as you think.

For articles:

Search for the TITLE OF THE JOURNAL with the phrase "impact factor." It should come back with a number that is the impact factor (which refers to how much impact the journal has). If the search comes back with any number at all, the article is probably fine.

screenshot showing impact factor search for the journal land use policy. Result says The 2021-2022 Journal's Impact IF of Land Use Policy is 5.398.

For books:

Search for the PUBLISHER in Google to determine whether this is an academic publisher. If it's a popular publisher (which means it publishes books for people to read for fun), the book might not be a scholarly source.

Screenshot showing Google search for Martinus Nijhoff publisher

Wikipedia will usually give reliable information about whether a publisher is academic or popular.

If you're uncertain about any of this, come to Research Help or ask a question in the Ask Us box on the library homepage!

The best way to evaluate sources you find via Google (or any search engine) is to fact check! This means:

  1. Leaving the source
  2. Looking up the the source or claim to see what sources you trust are saying about it.

Learn more in the infographic below.

Using SIFT to Evaluate Sources